 |
The Buddhist
Transformation of China ...
... or the Chinese
Transformation of Buddhism?
Buddhism’s introduction
into China met resistance from what
was already a vigorous intellectual and cultural tradition based on
Confucian classics and Daoist religion. Confucianists were not
impressed with Buddhist monasticism, which they felt abandoned family
and society, going against the responsibilities of filial piety. The
Buddhist belief in rebirth was also incompatible with the veneration of
ancestors. Daoists were disappointed that the Buddhists could not
provide elixirs and practices that led to the immortality they sought.
On the other hand, as we shall see, early on, Buddhists used Daoist
terms and concepts to convey their ideas. We will also see that in the
process of its inculturation, Buddhism adapted to Chinese culture. For
example, given the Daoist value of harmony and nature, Chinese Buddhism
emphasized the experience of the interdependence of phenomena and the
living out of that experience through simplicity and naturalness in
daily life. Also given the Confucian values of human perfectability,
sagehood, and social harmony, Chinese Buddhism emphasized the
Bodhisattva Path, the universal ideal of Buddhahood, and contributing
to the social good. (BIBE, 224)

The
Indigenous Traditions
6th to 3rd Centuries BCE
Master
You [You Ruo]
said, “Among those who are filial sons and good brothers, few
indeed are inclined to wrong their superiors. As for those who are
disinclined to wrong their superiors, there have never been any who are
inclined to create disorder. The Noble Person attends to the root, for
it is by establishing the root that the Way [Tao/Dao] is born. To be
filial and
fraternal — is this not the root of humaneness?” (Sources of Chinese
Tradition, 45 [Analects,
1:2])
|
 |
The questioner said, “The Classic of Filiality
says, ‘Our body, limbs, hair, and skin are all received from our
fathers and mothers. We dare not injure them.’ When Zengzi was about to
die, he bared his hands and feet [to show that he had preserved them
from harm]. But now the monks shave their heads. How this violates the
sayings of the sages and is out of keeping with the way of the filial!”
(Sources of Chinese
Tradition, 424)
The questioner said, “Now of felicities
there is none greater than the continuation of one’s line, of unfilial
conduct there is none worse than childlessness. The monks forsake wife
and children, reject property and wealth. Some do not marry all their
lives. How opposed this conduct is to felicity and filiality!” (Sources of Chinese
Tradition, 424)
The questioner said, “Confucius said, ‘The
barbarians with a ruler are not so good as the Chinese without one.’
Mencius criticized Chen Xiang for rejecting his own education to adopt
the ways of [the foreign teacher] Xu Xing, saying ‘I have heard of
using what is Chinese to change what is barbarian, but I have never
heard of using what is barbarian to change what is Chinese.’ You, sir,
at the age of twenty learned the Way of Yao, Shun, Confucius, and the
Duke of Zhou. But now you have rejected them and instead have taken up
the arts of the barbarians. Is this not a great error?” (Sources of Chinese
Tradition, 425)
|
The Blessed One said: “If a child
nurtures
its
parents by indulging their tastes for flavorful delicacies, by pleasing
their ears with well-liked heavenly music, by dressing them splendidly
in choice garments, by carrying them on their shoulders to the ends of
the world, and repaying their kindness throughout their lives —
can
this be called filial piety?”
The monks replied: “There is
no
greater model of filial piety than this.”
But the Blessed One
said: “This is
not really filial piety! If parents are stubborn and ignorant and
do
not revere the Triple Gem [i.e. the Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha],
if they are malicious and tyrannical, if they steal with impunity, if
they have illicit sexual relations, if they use false language in
defiance of the Way, if they are addicted to riotous behavior, if they
are against righteousness and truth, if they are wicked and feisty,
then their child should strive to admonish them in order to enlighten
them. And if this does not work and they still remain
unenlightened,
the child should take further steps to convert them. ... And if this
still does not make them alter their ways, the child should wail and
cry and stop taking food and drink. For the parents naturally
love and
feel tenderly toward their child, and although they do not understand,
they would be anguished if it should die. In this way, they would
be
forced to capitulate and respect the Way. ...
In a world without filial piety,
only this can bring about filial piety. Only this is able to make
parents leave evil behind and do good, so that they come to honor the
five precepts and stick to the threefold refuge [of the Triple
Gem]. ... If one is not successful in changing one’s parents’ ways by
means of the Triple Gem, then even if one cultivates filial conduct,
one would not truly be filial.” (The Experience of
Buddhism, 290-291) |

|
Kshitigarbha: "Earth Womb"
Bodhisattva
Chinese: Dizang Pusa / Japanese: Jizo Bosatsu
|

Daoism
The
transmission of the actual teachings of Buddhism into China
necessitated the translation of Buddhist texts. These translations
began to be made in earnest during the second century C.E. ... This
early
work of translating texts and preaching the Dharma continued into the
third century. Thus, the ground was prepared for the great Dharmaraksa
(born 230), a native of Dunhuang, who established intellectual
respectability for Buddhism in north China from 266 to 308. ... With
the
loss of north China to the barbarians, many Buddhists from that region
traveled to other parts of China, thus spreading Dharmaraksa’s
intellectual and disciplined style of Buddhism. ...
During
the fourth century, some of the more intellectual Buddhist monastics in
the south of China were using Daoist and Neo-Daoists [sic]
terms and concepts
to aid in the translation of Buddhist texts and in the understanding of
Buddhist ideas. For example, some Neo-Daoists held, based on original
Daoist texts, that the world of phenomena is the “functioning” of the
Dao, which is itself Ultimate Reality. All phenomena are the
self-determinations of the Dao, formed by the Dao’s dynamic
functioning. This means that the “essence” of all things is the Dao
itself. The Neo-Daoists referred to the phenomena of the world as
“being” and the ultimate and formless Dao that is the essence of all
phenomena as “non-being.” Buddhist scholars used these distinctions in
discussing the Mahayana notion of emptiness. Emptiness was understood
to be, like the Dao, the causal source and formless essence of all
phenomena. As essence, emptiness is non-being; but in its functioning
of dependent arising, it takes form as being. (BIBE, 224-226)

|
A way
that can be way’d is not the Constant
Way;
A
name that can be named is not the Constant Name.
The
nameless is the beginning of Heaven and
Earth;
The
named is the mother of all things.
Thus
be constantly without desire
in
order to observe its subtlety,
Yet
constantly have desire
in
order to observe its manifestation.
These
two arise together,
But
differ in name.
Their
unity is therefore called a mystery.
A
mystery on top of a mystery—
The gateway of
all subtleties!
|
In time, some Buddhist scholars came to realize that
looking at Buddhism through a Daoist lens could be distorting the
meaning of Buddhist texts. ... A number of popular sutras
were retranslated, and new translations were completed. Kumarajiva’s
translation of Madhyamika texts, the Perfection of Wisdom literature,
the Lotus Sutra, and the Vimalakirti Sutra
sowed the seeds of a deeper understanding of Buddhism in China.This
clearer understanding would later flower in a number of highly creative
schools of Chinese Buddhist thought. In this way, the inculturation of
Buddhism in China took a giant step forward. (BIBE, 226)
Cook Ting was cutting up an ox for
Lord
Wen-hui. At every touch of his hand, every heave of his shoulder,
every move of his
feet, every thrust of his knee — zip! zoop! He slithered the knife along with a
zing,
and all was in perfect rhythm, as though he were performing the dance
of
the Mulberry Grove or keeping time to the Ching-shou music.
“Ah, this
is
marvelous!” said Lord
Wen-hui. “Imagine
skill
reaching such heights!”
Cook
Ting laid
down his
knife and replied, “What I care about is the Way, which goes beyond
skill. When I first began cutting up oxen,
all I could see was
the ox itself. After three years I no
longer saw the whole
ox. And now — now I go
at it by spirit (shen) and don’t look with my
eyes. Perception
and understanding have come to a stop and spirit moves where it
wants. I go along with the natural makeup, strike in the big
hollows, guide
the
knife through the big openings, and follow things as they are. So
I
never touch the smallest ligament or tendon, much less a main joint.
“A good cook changes his knife once a
year — because
he cuts. A mediocre cook changes his knife once a month — because he hacks. I’ve had this knife of mine for
nineteen years and I’ve cut up thousands of oxen with it, and yet the
blade is as good
as though it had just come from the grindstone. There are spaces
between
the joints, and the blade of the knife has really no thickness. If
you insert what has no thickness into such spaces, then there’s plenty
of
room — more than enough
for
the
blade to play about in. That’s why after nineteen years the blade
of
my knife is still as good as when it first came from the grindstone.
“However,
whenever
I
come
to a complicated place, I size up the difficulties, tell myself to
watch
out and be careful, keep my eyes on what I’m doing, work very slowly,
and
move the knife with the greatest subtlety, until — flop! the whole thing comes apart like a clod of earth
crumbling
to the ground. I stand there holding the knife and look all
around
me, completely satisfied and reluctant to move on, and then I wipe off
the
knife and put it away.”
“Excellent!” said
Lord
Wen-hui. “I have heard the words of Cook Ting and learned how to
care for life!”
(Chuang
Tzu: Basic Writings, 46-7)
Another
notion that was of great interest to Chinese Buddhists at the time of Kumarajiva was Tathagata-garbha,
a term the Chinese rendered as “Buddha-nature.” The Lotus Sutra, and later the Nirvana Sutra,
introduced to China the notion that there is within us an innate
Awakening that can develop through religious practice into the full
Buddhahood. The early Chinese understanding of Buddha-nature was also
influenced by Daoism. The Daoists believed that people have an inner
spirit of light that manifests the power of the Dao, the creative
source of the universe. Dao Sheng (fl. 397-432), another student of
Kumarajiva, argued that Buddha-nature should not be understood as a
particular spiritual power, but should be understood as one universal
reality that is the same in all beings. He also taught that
Buddha-nature cannot be grasped gradually, but only all at once, in a
single stroke of sudden Awakening. Dao Sheng’s teaching about “sudden”
Awakening in which one “recognizes one’s innate Buddha-nature”
contributed to a line of Buddhist thought that was influential
throughout all of East Asia. (BIBE, 226-227) |
|
|