|
Laozi and the Birth of Daoism
 The interpretation of Laozi’s Daodejing (Tao-Te Ching) is notoriously difficult. To begin with, there may never have been a person named Laozi; secondly, the book was most likely not entitled Daodejing
by its original author. Furthermore, it may not even have been a
monograph written by one person. The historical placement of the book
is also controversial. The traditional view held that it was written by
someone named Lao Dan, who was senior to Confucius (in the sixth
century BCE), and that it was written on his exit to the West in
response to the request of the gatekeeper. Another popular traditional
view placed the work in the fourth or third century BCE, as written by
someone named Li Er, who used the name Laozi (meaning “Master
Lao” or “the Old Master”) to hide his own identity. A
more accepted view among contemporary [Western] commentators is that this book
was a compilation of various sayings of different people, and the
present version was completed around the first century AD. (An Introduction to Chinese Philosophy, 131)
 |
Issues in the Textual History of the Daodejing
The discovery of two Laozi silk manuscripts at Mawangdui,
near Changsha, Hunan province in 1973 marks an important milestone in
modern Laozi research. The manuscripts, identified simply as
“A” (jia) and “B” (yi), were
found in a tomb that was sealed in 168 B.C.E. The texts themselves can
be dated earlier, the “A” manuscript being the older of
the two, copied in all likelihood before 195 B.C.E. (see Lau 1982,
Boltz 1984, and Henricks 1989). ... The two manuscripts contain all the chapters that are
found in the current Laozi, although the chapters follow a
different order in a few places. For example, in both manuscripts, the
sections that appear as chapters 80 and 81 in the
current Laozi come immediately after a section that
corresponds with chapter 66 of the present text. Both manuscripts are similarly divided into two parts, but in contrast
with the current version, in reverse order; i.e., both manuscripts
begin with the Dejing, corresponding to chapter 38 of the
received text. “Part one” of the “B”
manuscript ends with the editorial notation, “Virtue, 3,041
[characters],” while the last line of “Part two”
reads: “Dao, 2,426.” Does this mean that the classic
should be renamed? One scholar, in fact, has adopted the
title Dedaojing (Te-Tao ching) for his translation
of the Mawangdui Laozi (Henricks 1989). ... If the order is deliberate, does it imply that the
“original” Laozi gives priority to sociopolitical
issues? This raises important questions for interpretation. ... Until recently, the Mawangdui manuscripts have held the pride of place
as the oldest extant manuscripts of the Laozi. In late 1993,
the excavation of a tomb (identified as M1) in Guodian, Jingmen city,
Hubei province, has yielded among other things some 800 bamboo slips,
of which 730 are inscribed, containing over 13,000 Chinese
characters. Some of these, amounting to about 2,000 characters, match
the Laozi (see Allan and Williams 2000, and Henricks
2000). The tomb is located near the old capital of the state of Chu
and is dated around 300 B.C.E. Robbers entered the tomb before it was
excavated, although the extent of the damage is uncertain. The bamboo texts, written in a Chu script, have been transcribed into
standard Chinese and published under the title Guodian Chumu
zhujian (Beijing: Wenwu, 1998), which on the basis of the size
and shape of the slips, calligraphy, and other factors divides
the Laozi material into three groups. Group A contains
thirty-nine bamboo slips, which correspond in whole or in part to the
following chapters of the present text: 19, 66, 46, 30, 15, 64, 37,
63, 2, 32, 25, 5, 16, 64, 56, 57, 55, 44, 40 and 9. Groups B and C are
smaller, with eighteen (chs. 59, 48, 20, 13, 41, 52, 45, 54) and
fourteen slips (chs. 17, 18, 35, 31, 64), respectively. ... Two approaches to the making of the Laozi warrant
consideration, for they bear directly on interpretation.
A linear “evolutionary” model of textual formation would
suggest that there was an original Laozi, by Lao Dan or of
unknown authorship, and that the Guodian Laozi was close to
or were abridged versions of this original text.
Concerned with the decline of Zhou rule, according to this view, the
original Laozi addressed above all issues of
governance. During the third century B.C.E., the Laozi had
undergone substantial change and grown into a longer and more complex
work, becoming in this process more polemical against the Confucian
and other schools of thought, and acquiring new material of stronger
metaphysical or cosmological interest. The Mawangdui manuscripts were
based on this mature version of the Laozi; the original
emphasis on politics, however, can still be detected in the placement
of the Dejing before the Daojing. Later versions
reversed this order and in so doing subsumed politics under a broader
philosophical vision of Dao as the beginning and end of all
beings.
The Guodian and Mawangdui manuscripts are certainly older than the
received text of the Laozi, but this does not necessarily
mean that they are therefore closer to the
“original,” if there was an original. As opposed
to a linear evolutionary model, it is conceivable that there were
several overlapping collections of sayings attributed to Laozi from
the start, each inhabiting a particular interpretive context, from
which different versions of the Laozi were derived. Although some key chapters in the current Laozi that deal
with the nature of Dao (e.g., chs. 1, 14) are not found in the Guodian
corpus, the idea that the Dao is “born before heaven and
earth,” for example, which is found in chapter 25 of the
received text is already present. The critical claim that “being
[you] is born of nonbeing [wu]” in chapter 40
also figures in the Guodian “A” text. This seems to argue
against any suggestion that the Laozi, and for that matter
ancient Chinese philosophical works in general were not interested or
lacked the ability to engage in abstract philosophic thinking, an
assumption that sometimes appears to underlie evolutionary approaches
to the development of Chinese philosophy. ...

[I]t seems clear that different written collections
of Laozi sayings circulated among the educated elite during the fourth
century B.C.E. It is likely that they were based on earlier oral
traditions, and perhaps certain choice sayings were inscribed on
bamboo, in different collections according to different interpretive
emphases, even before 400 B.C.E. However, until confirmed by new
archaeological evidence, it would be more critically responsible to
leave open the time, the location and the way in which these written
collections of Laozi sayings were first formed. The Guodian texts would be examples of these written collections that
surfaced during the fourth century B.C.E., and there is no reason not
to believe there were others, perhaps even longer
collections. Overlapping in some cases and with varying emphases in
others, they address both the nature of Dao and Daoist
government. These were then developed in several ways — e.g., some
collections were combined; new sayings were added; and explanatory
comments, illustrations, and elaboration on individual sayings were
integrated into the text. The demand for textual uniformity rose when
the Laozi gained recognition, and consequently the different
textual traditions eventually gave way to the received text of
the Laozi. (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Laozi)
| |