Historical
Context
As
in all Reacting to the Past
games, a
clash of ideas lies at the heart of the exercise. In this case it is a
clash
that predates World War II by nearly 100 years, and stems from the
arrival of
Commodore Matthew Perry’s American fleet of “black ships” in Edo (later
Tokyo)
Bay in 1853. At that time Perry and his men confronted a culture that
had to a
large extent shut itself off from the rest of the world for more than
200
years. It was a culture that had changed little during that time, and
one that
lacked both the economic base and the military power to compete on the
world
stage. (Game Book [GB], 28)
The Meiji
Restoration
Meirokusha
The Meiji Six Society

|
In
the early 1870s a group of intellectuals formed a group called the
Meirokusha, whose goal was “to promote
civilization and enlightenment.” The members of this organization
claimed that
Japan’s humiliation was a wake-up call, and that the nation’s weakness
was the
result of the “superstition, irrationality, ignorance, and backwardness
of its
people.” The leading figure of the Meirokusha
was Fukuzawa Yukichi, who in the 1860s had traveled both to the United
States
and Europe, and served as chief translator for the old shogunate.
Fukuzawa
insisted that simply learning western technological methods was
insufficient; a
national renewal, he argued, would require a new mindset on the part of
the
Japanese. As he wrote in 1872:
Schools,
industries, armies and navies are the mere external forms of
civilization. They
are not difficult to produce. All that is needed is the money to pay
for them. Yet
there remains something immaterial, something that cannot be seen or
heard,
bought or sold, lent or borrowed. It pervades the whole nation and its
influence is so strong that without it none of the schools or the other
external forms would be of the slightest use. This supremely important
thing we
must call the spirit of civilization. (GB, 29)
The
Enlightenment included a range of ideas centered on the value of human
happiness, the pursuit of knowledge obtained by means of reason and the
evidence of the senses, and ideals such as natural law, liberty,
progress, toleration, fraternity, constitutional
government, and separation of church and state. (Age of Enlightenment)
|
The
Spirit of Independence
The
“spirit of independence,” by which Fukuzawa meant the realization that
all human beings are born free and equal in moral worth. He complained
that indoctrination with Confucian philosophy, which emphasized
hierarchy, had left the common people of Japan “slavish and servile.
... They are just as meek and obedient as pet dogs.” Such people might
be taught certain methods, but would remain so uncritical of authority
that they could never bring lasting reform for their country. (GB, 29)
|
The
Spirit of Rationality
The
“spirit of rationality,” in which individuals rejected superstitions
and behaved in a manner that reflected the use of reason, rather than
unthinking reliance on tradition or the example of others. This, he
argued, was the true wellspring of science — a sense of skepticism
toward received knowledge and a willingness to seek answers for
oneself. Paradoxically, he sometimes criticized along these lines those
who enthusiastically embraced western trends, claiming that they often
did so for the wrong reasons. For example, he believed that it was
eminently reasonable for a Japanese man to have his hair styled in
western fashion, but he feared that many of his countrymen were doing
so simply because western styles had become popular. Rather, western
hairstyles were good because they allowed the hair to serve its natural
function of keeping the top of one’s head warm, as opposed to the
traditional Japanese style, in which the top of the head was shaved.
(GB, 29-30)
|
The
Spirit of Enterprise
The
“spirit of enterprise,” in which it was acceptable for individuals to
pursue their self-interest. This meant not being afraid to attempt to
improve one’s place in society, rather than passively accepting the
station into which one was born. It meant that it was acceptable — even
commendable — to seek one’s own happiness according to one’s own
lights, whether this meant by financial success or some other standard.
At the same time, it meant accepting personal responsibility for one’s
condition. (GB, 30)
|
The
Spirit of Progress
The
“spirit of progress,” in which individuals recognized that civilization
was not simply a means to wealth and military power, but rather a stage
in a larger process by which humankind moved ever closer to perfection.
Japan, he claimed, had passed through earlier stages such as konton
(primitive chaos) and yaban
(savagery), and now stood at hankai
(semi-civilization). Although Europeans and Americans still had much
more progress to make, they had reached bummei (civilization), and
Japan must now seek to do likewise. (GB, 30)
|
What
do you think of this response to the "challenge of the West"?

How
does it present the relationship between "tradition" and "modernity"?
|

|
 |
 |

|
Opening
Ceremony of the Imperial Diet, 1890
The Development
of Ultranationalism
All of this could not
help but provoke a reaction, and even at the time complaints could be
heard that westernization was going too far. Motoda Nagazane,
an educational adviser to Emperor Meiji, denounced what he saw as
efforts “to convert Japanese into facsimiles of Europeans and
Americans,” and specifically argued against the use of western
textbooks in Japanese public schools. The encouragement of
individualism, he claimed, would turn students into troublemakers and
delinquents. Instead young Japanese should be trained in “the Imperial
ancestral precepts” of “benevolence, duty, loyalty, and filial piety.”
Part of the reaction against western culture was a
growing belief that, as the only East Asian country to rise to world
power status while resisting European colonialism, Japan had an
historic role to play as the champion of pan-Asianism. Advocates of
this view held that Japan represented a specifically Asian path toward
modernity, one that could and should be followed by countries such as
Korea and China. European imperialism stood in the way of this goal;
therefore, Japan must do more than simply serve as a model — it must
also strive to liberate East Asia from foreign domination. (GB,
30)

|
When Japan,
China and Manchukuo cooperate, the world will be at peace!
During
the late 19th century such attitudes merely served [as a] a check
against
what otherwise might have grown into a tendency to abandon all that was
traditionally Japanese in favor of western attitudes. However,
anti-western
sentiment began to harden in the early 20th century, in part as a
result of as the growing rift between Japan and the United States. It
found its
clearest expression in the proliferation of organizations calling for
the
return to traditional agrarian values, the elimination of capitalism
(associated with Japan’s zaibatsu),
the purging from Japanese culture of western influences, and an
aggressive
foreign policy aimed at liberating East Asia from western imperialism.
Many of
these called themselves traditionalists, and in some ways they did
invoke the
values of an earlier time in Japanese history, but to a large extent
the
tradition that they championed was borrowed selectively and adapted to
suit
their purposes, and in some cases wholly invented.

|
One
of the ultranationalist movement’s leading lights was Kita Ikki, who in 1919
published An Outline Plan for the
Reorganization of Japan (excerpts from which may be found on
pages 131-139
of this Game Book). Kita called for a restructuring of the government
that
placed the emperor at the very center, and which eliminated the
influence of
the zaibatsu and the party
politicians. Under Kita’s plan large corporations would be
nationalized, and
strict limits would be placed on the amount of land or money that an
individual
or family could own. His new Japan would then dedicate itself to
liberating the
peoples of Asia from the yoke of European imperialism. Kita’s work
inspired a
generation of young activists, particularly in the army; so much so
that in the
wake of an attempted coup d’etat in 1936 by young army officers Kita
was
arrested, tried, and executed for complicity. (GB, 31)
The
failure of the 1936 coup — and many others like it in the 1930s — did
nothing to
undermine support for traditionalist and ultranationalist causes, and
membership in organizations espousing these ideas continued to surge
throughout
the decade. By 1940 there were at least 1,000 such organizations in
Japan,
claiming a total membership of at least half a million people. Of
course, given
these numbers there were inevitably areas of disagreement among them,
but they
tended to possess a set of core beliefs that included ...
Traditional Confucianism

Bushido
State Shinto
(cf. GB, 31-3)
How
does this vision of Japan compare with Fukuzawa Yukichi's?

Does
it resolve the tension between "tradition" and "modernity"?
Most
of the ultranationalists’ beliefs were affirmed in a publication called
Fundamentals of our
National Polity (see
pages 58-84 for excerpts). Drafted by a committee of university faculty
and
government officials, it was published in 1937, and the first printing
of
300,000 was distributed to all of the nation’s teachers. This short
book
credited Japan with a unique ability to “assimilate and sublimate”
ideas from
China and India, taking from them what was useful and discarding what
was
destructive. All of the recent instability in Japan, it claimed, had
been the
result of a failure to do the same with western ideas. The Japanese had
understood the value of western industrial methods, but had at the same
time
unthinkingly accepted western individualism and rationalism — both of which were
destructive to the kokutai.
The
country would only truly succeed once these dangerous notions had been
eradicated.
With
the Fundamentals of our National
Polity
established as official orthodoxy, it was clear by 1940 that the
traditionalists had the upper hand in their debate with the
westernizers. The
high command of the army embraced traditionalist ideas, almost to a
man. Considerable
numbers of ultranationalists could be found in the navy and bureaucracy
as
well, and there were even some among the emperor’s closest advisors.
Meanwhile,
the state-controlled media provided a steady stream of ultranationalist
propaganda to the people of Japan. While, as Storry points out, it
would be
erroneous to claim that all Japanese believed themselves to be
descendants of
the gods, “with few exceptions they were convinced they had a
birthright envied
but unrivalled by other nations of the world.”

|
On
the other hand, some voices could still be heard resisting these
trends. There [were] still suggestions that it was wiser to maintain
friendly relations with
the West, even if it meant backing away from the dream of pan-Asianism.
Even
some believers in pan-Asianism started to question whether the war in
China was
being carried out for the benefit of Asia in general, or whether Japan
was
simply practicing its own form of imperialism. But it was becoming
dangerous to
espouse such ideas, at least publicly. The ultranationalists
increasingly
regarded pro-western sentiments as insults to the kokutai, and they had again and
again demonstrated their
willingness to employ violence to avenge such insults. (Game Book, 34)

|
|
The Game
Victory
is accomplished by satisfying the objectives listed on your role sheet
and (if
you are not an indeterminate) your faction advisory. Many of those
objectives
reflect efforts to influence policy: for example, some characters seek
to
conclude an alliance with Germany, while others seek to prevent it;
some want
to reform Japan’s economy, while others oppose this. Other objectives
are
personal; for example, some characters seek to obtain a position on the
cabinet or ensure that a particular petition is either blocked or
approved. In addition, each faction has an
outcome that will result in an
automatic loss — so make sure that you pay attention to both personal
and faction objectives. At
the end of the game, your prestige point total will be calculated to
determine whether you “win” (at least 5 points), “lose” (less than 3
points), or “draw” (3 or 4 points). For more details, see pp. 35-48 of
the Game Book.
Students are responsible for turning in at least
two pieces of written work, each of which should be written in
character and draw on the
ideas expressed in the course readings. Papers
will generally take one of the following forms (though other forms are
possible with Professor Hoffert’s approval):
- A petition to be considered by the cabinet, and,
if approved, submitted to the
Emperor. Each petition should include an argument for some initiative
(see
“Petitions and Initiatives”), or more than one if they are related in
some way.
The petition is due before the
session in which you intend the Cabinet to consider it.
- A speech given either in support of or in
opposition to a petition that will be
brought before the Cabinet. Speeches are due before the session in
which the petition is being considered.
- A
statement offered for or against a defendant in a trial, written either
by the
defendant or someone else. For example, it might be a defense of
someone
implicated in an assassination, demonstrating that the defendant was
merely
following the proper principles of bushido.
If the gamemaster finds this appeal particularly convincing he or she
may award
a bonus (or penalty) to the die roll to determine the defendant’s fate.
Such
statements must be submitted before
the session in which the trial is to take place.
- An
ambassador will be required to make regular reports to his home
government,
informing it of recent developments. Note that as players in the game,
ambassadors will be privy to information that they never would have had
historically. Reports, therefore, should not contain specific details
that an
ambassador would not have known. For instance, a report from the
British
ambassador announcing that Japan is about to invade Southeast Asia
would not be
permitted. However, it would be appropriate to write about something
that Japan
has already done, drawing on the tenor of cabinet discussions for
insight as to
why Tokyo has decided on such a course.
- If
Ogata Taketora is in the game, players may wish to contribute
editorials to the Asahi Shimbun.
Ogata is instructed to
prepare two editorial sections, one for Game Session 3 and the other
for Game
Session 5.
- A diary entry giving the player’s impression of
the
events going on in Tokyo during this period. These may be turned in at
any
point in the game.
Grades
| 3% |
Reading
Quiz
|
| 12% |
Two
Best Written Assignments (500-word minimum; 6% each)
|
| 5% |
Participation |
Read
all of the contextual material, documents, and sources before the game
begins ... and then go back and reread these materials throughout the
game. A second reading while in role will deepen your understanding and
alter your perspective: ideas take on new dimensions when seen through
the eyes of a partisan actor. Players who have carefully read the
materials and who know the rules of the game will invariably do better
than those who rely on general impressions and uncertain recollections.
|
|

|
|