Early Modern
China
Global Connections
~ East and West
 |
Even to suggest that
East Asia had an early modern period may be somewhat surprising. The
word modern
comes from Late Latin, and the concept of modernity emerged
originally in the specific context of European history. There is,
furthermore, no denying the defining role that was played by western
Europe (and its overseas colonial offspring, including the United
States) in shaping much of what we think of as the modern world. With
regard to non-Western civilizations, there is still a widespread
popular tendency to imagine them as societies that had been
changelessly
traditional until only relatively recently,
when the process of modernization (often assumed to be synonymous with
Westernization) finally started as a direct consequence of contact with
the modern West.
East Asian history has long been
conventionally divided into
two major parts, premodern and modern, with the point of transition
placed somewhere in the nineteenth century. Yet, paradoxically, the use
of paper money, printing, gunpowder, urbanization, market-based
commercialization, complex bureaucratic administration, and a
relatively fluid meritocratic sociopolitical order based on the
examination system all make Song Dynasty China (960-1279) seem
curiously modern already 1,000 years ago! The idea of a changeless
static East Asia, at any rate, is a fantasy, sustained only by lack of
historical knowledge. (HEA, 173)
|
Traditional vs.
Modern Society
In the view of Michel Foucault
... “modernity” as a historical category is marked by
developments such as a questioning or rejection of tradition;
the prioritization of individualism, freedom and formal equality; faith in
inevitable social, scientific and technological progress, rationalization and professionalization, a movement from feudalism
(or agrarianism) toward capitalism
and the market economy, industrialization, urbanization
and secularization, the development of the nation-state, representative democracy, public education
(etc.) (Foucault
1977, 170–77). (Wikipedia/Modernity)
So,
when does “modernity” begin in China?
|
Given
China’s huge size, most of China’s trade has always been domestic. The
Ming government inadvertently helped facilitate internal trade by
reopening and maintaining the Grand Canal. Some 12,000
government barges plied this canal to bring tax grain from the south to
the capital at Beijing in the north, and the private vessels that also
took advantage of this manmade waterway, as well as of the many other
rivers and canals of south China, were beyond count. Increasing
regional
economic specialization further stimulated interregional domestic
trade. For example, concentration on the
cultivation of cotton for
textile production in the lower Yangzi River area created a local
demand for imported food that was satisfied by shipments of rice
from further upriver. By
the 1730s such shipments had reached a volume in excess of a billion
pounds a year. The invention, by at least Ming
times, of that
invaluable tool of trade, the abacus, is another indication of growing
commercialization. ...
At sea off the Ming coast, in any single day, there
might be
as many as 1,200 ships. Although much coastal shipping was for domestic
purposes, the volume of foreign trade was also substantial. Since the
Ming government viewed foreign trade with suspicion, however, a large
portion of this traffic operated outside the law, including both
smuggling and piracy. The contradiction between growing trade and
government restriction of it reached a climax in a period of
so-called “Japanese pirate” raiding (in Japanese, Wako; in Chinese, Wokou)
along the Ming coast, especially in the 1540s-1550s. Although actual
Japanese people were certainly among these pirates, many of the
seaborne marauders were really Chinese or Korean. (HEA, 174-5)
For
the first 142 years of the Ming Dynasty, the only legal
foreign trade had been what was conducted under the rubric of
formal diplomatic tribute missions (though these were sometimes merely
fictitious pretexts for trade, and there was much extralegal activity),
but in 1509, Guangzhou (English: Canton) was legally opened to
private merchants from tributary countries, and in 1567, a port in
Fujian Province was opened to private Chinese traders. By that date,
there was also already a permanent Portuguese presence on the southeast
coast of China. Conditions were significantly changing, and China was
beginning to participate in the truly global trade routes — which now
included the Americas — that had been opened by the early modern
European Age of
Exploration. (HEA, 175)
Andre
Gunder Frank has recently argued that Europe, in its early modern Age
of Exploration, did not really pull the rest of the world into a
European-centered economic system — at least, not initially. “Instead,
Europe belatedly joined ... an already existing world economy,” in
which, if any location could truly be called “central” prior to about
1800, “it was China.” Early modern Europeans, moreover, still had no
product that would sell consistently in China, except for money itself.
But in the matter of cash, the Europeans were fortunate. Between 1492
and 1800, some 85 percent of the world’s total silver supply, and 70
percent of its gold, came from the new European colonies in the
Americas. In Ming China, raw silver literally was money, and early
modern Europeans used a substantial portion of their New World silver
to pay for imported Chinese luxury products such as porcelain, silk,
lacquerware, and (later) tea. (HEA, 176-7)
The world’s largest economy at the time
desperately needed
silver so it could expand. By the 1530s, the situation had become so
severe and
the potential profits from the silver trade so great that merchants
dared to
ignore the government’s ban on trade with foreign nations.
...
The amount of silver
flowing into China reached new heights after the first silver from the
New
World reached Asia. The Spanish discovered
huge reserves of silver in Peru in the
1540s, but only thirty years later did they perfect the use of mercury
to
refine it. Spanish galleons carried the silver from the New World to Spain’s colony in the Philippines,
at Manila, where Chinese merchants from
Fujian and Guangdong
traded Chinese goods, most often tea, porcelain, and high-quality silks.
... One scholar estimates that between 1570 and 1600, 7.5 percent of
the total output of silver from Peruvian mines ended up in China, where
it constituted an infusion equal to eight times China’s own silver
stocks. The size of the Chinese community in Manila provides an
indirect measure of the growth in trade between Spain and China. In
1570, forty Chinese lived in Manila. By 1600, the Chinese community had
exploded to fifteen thousand people. (The
Open Empire, 377)
New World
silver
transformed the Chinese economy down to its roots, although the central
government never formally acknowledged it. The tax system established
by the
Ming founder presumed a barter economy in which individual cultivators
paid
their taxes in grain and labor .... As the sixteenth century
progressed, though, and as more New World
silver entered the economy, certain areas began to pay their taxes with
money.
The first stage toward commutation was to use cloth; as the century
progressed,
this changed to silver. ...
Most
taxpayers ended up paying taxes every year. Their
tax was assessed partially on the basis of how many able-bodied men
were in the
household and partially on the basis of landholdings. With the
exception of
households that performed certain labor services, such as delivering
grain,
most households paid a tax in silver in place of their original labor
assignment. (The
Open Empire, 377-8)
|
.
|
Early
Ming policies forbidding private foreign trade may have discouraged
foreign ships from coming to China,
causing Muslim traders to withdraw from China’s coasts and weakening
the linkage between Indian Ocean and Southeast Asian trade that had
developed under Mongol hegemony — which had included a Chinese
commercial presence in southern India. But the early
Ming restrictions also had the unintended consequence of giving Chinese
merchants a near monopoly of China’s maritime foreign trade. Chinese
people, who had already been active in Southeast Asian trade since late
Tang times, fanned out across Southeast Asia in increasing numbers
beginning especially after about 1500. These ethnic Chinese merchants
may have often been unattached to any particular Chinese government ...
but they were very active throughout Southeast Asia, and commonly
retained some sense of Chinese identity. (HEA, 176)
The Arrival of
the West
In the seventeenth century, the Dutch East India Company
(the VOC) was the largest company in the world, and the Dutch became
the most dynamic European presence in Pacific waters. Although the
focus of their attention came to be directed at what is now called
Indonesia, the Dutch also attempted to trade with China. In the first
half of the seventeenth century, the Dutch imported some 3 million
pieces of Chinese porcelain (which was often simply called “china,” or
chinaware) into Europe and established a successful outpost on the
island of Taiwan. On Taiwan the Dutch erected their
second-largest
fortress in Asia, and there they purchased silk from Chinese merchants
to exchange for silver in Japan. ... Europeans
were therefore among the participants in China’s overseas trade by the
seventeenth century, but they hardly constituted a dominant presence.
But Europe had already begun to make an impact on China. The
telescope, for example, was introduced to China by 1618, within thirty
years of its European invention around 1590. A European-style map, with
captions written in Chinese, was prepared by the Italian Catholic
missionary Matteo Ricci (1552-1610) in
1584. This was quickly copied
and printed by the Chinese. A copy of a revised version of this map was
eventually even hung in large panels on the wall of the emperor’s
palace in Beijing. In addition to his mapmaking contributions, Ricci
also worked with the Chinese scholar Xu Guangqi (1562-1633) to produce
the first good Chinese translation of Euclid in 1607. This same Chinese
scholar, Xu Guangqi, later rose to the highest office in the Ming
government and became a baptized Christian, taking the Christian name
Paul.
Matteo
Ricci was a Jesuit. The Jesuits were a Roman Catholic
counterreformation order that produced some of the best-educated minds
in seventeenth-century Europe. Jesuits were expected to undergo a
nine-year course of study that included mathematics and astronomy,
classical philosophy, art, and the humanities as well as Christian
theology. ... Matteo Ricci became the first European Christian
missionary since Mongol times to be allowed to reside in Beijing. Ricci
may have also been the first European ever to learn to speak the
Chinese language proficiently. With his profound erudition, scientific
knowledge, and accommodating approach, Matteo Ricci made a favorable
impression on many Chinese. The Jesuit mission to China enjoyed a
measure of real success, and by the end of the seventeenth century,
there may have been 200,000 Chinese Christian converts. (HEA, 177-8)

The Manchu Conquest
Qing Dynasty
(1644-1911)
The
Qing Dynasty was a vast multiethnic conquest empire that, by the
eighteenth century, may have ruled over as much as 40 percent of the
world’s total population. It had three official languages, Manchu,
Mongol, and Chinese, with Tibetan also enjoying
prominence. The eighteenth-century Qianlong Emperor (r. 1736-1796)
reportedly was able to speak Manchu, Mongol, Chinese, Tibetan, Uighur,
and Tangut. During the seventeenth century, the Manchu language
remained dominant in government, and even in the eighteenth century,
Manchu was still commonly spoken at meetings of the Grand Council. But
the Banner People made up only 1 percent of the total population of
their empire, and it became a struggle for many of them to maintain
competence in their own language. The Chinese language tended to
prevail, and today Manchu is nearly extinct as a living language. (HEA, 184)
|
The Success of
the Qing
& the Failure
of Modernity
|
|
[Qianlong and his
ministers maintained] the
Confucian tradition of political thought that idealized low taxes and
minimal government, since whatever the ruler took was a diminution of a
fixed store of goods available
to the people. The ruler’s duties were to find and employ the
most
talented and unselfish ministers, to listen to them, and to set an
example
to ministers and people of virtuous conduct and moderate expenditure;
to
seek to increase revenues in order to “enrich the state and strengthen
the
military” was to be distracted from these fundamental duties and to go
the
route of Qin. The defeat of the Wang Anshi policies had been the
last
time that more dynamic and growth-oriented state policies had been
seriously considered. (Mountain of Fame, 239)
A
brilliant ruler, a scholar, and an all-around personality ... [Kang Xi]
had a genuine love of scholarship and succeeded in attracting to his
side some of the best Chinese literati of the time. A small group was
attached to his personal study, and they and wider committees of
scholars collaborated in works to which he wrote prefaces. Thus
there appeared under Kang Xi’s patronage the great dictionary
of some 40,000 characters, a collection devoted to calligraphy and
painting, an extensive treatise of geography, and a complete edition of
the works of Zhu Xi. The vast encyclopedia, Tu Shu Ji Cheng, begun in the
seventeenth century, was published in 1728.
In his capacity as moral leader of the
nation, Kang Xi published in 1670 the Sacred
Edict,
an amplification of earlier imperial maxims of the fourteenth century,
which exhorted the people to be filial and thrifty, to value
scholarship and avoid unorthodoxy, and to respect the law and pay their
taxes. (China: Its History and Culture,
142-3)
To
preserve the greatness of Chinese culture, Qianlong ... ordered a
massive
compilation to be made of the most famous literary and historical works
of the past. Known as the Four Treasuries (siku
quanshu)
from its four main components of classics, histories, philosophy, and
miscellaneous literary works, this was not just a selection of passages
on given topics, as was the Gujin
tushu jicheng
(the encyclopedia brought forth under Qianlong’s grandfather and
father); rather, it was a complete anthology, with learned
introductions, into which the works selected were copied in their
entirety. The assembling of this collection, which ended up comprising
3,450 complete works and commentaries on 6,750 others, filled 36,000
manuscript volumes and took ten years to complete. It is one of the
great achievements of Chinese bibliography. (SMC,
98-9)
|
The Decline of
Christianity
The
total number of Jesuit missionaries who came to China remained small,
however, and they were reluctant to increase the number of priests by
ordaining
native Chinese, making it difficult to adequately serve a large
Chinese Christian population. By the eighteenth century, moreover, the
Jesuit order was under assault in Europe itself. In East Asia the
Jesuits had made a conscious decision to adopt local manners and
culture, in a policy known as cultural accommodation, to make
themselves more acceptable to East Asians. In China, the Jesuits also
chose to treat Confucianism as a secular philosophy rather than a
religion, and therefore viewed it as somewhat compatible with
Christianity. The argument was that Confucius should be no more
objectionable to a good Christian than such other great pagan
philosophers as Plato or Aristotle. Even the traditional Chinese
offering of food at household ancestral tablets, and some of the
rituals conducted for the spirit of Confucius, might be tolerated as
purely social obligations rather than heathen religion.
Other Catholic orders, however, particularly the
Dominicans and Franciscans, were outraged by this Jesuit tolerance of
Confucian rites. Serious criticism of the Jesuit approach began as
early as the 1640s, and, altogether, no fewer than eight popes became
involved in deciding the so-called rites controversy. In 1704, a
Vatican decree banned Christian participation in Confucian rites, and a
papal bull (Ex illa die) in
1715 further reinforced this decision. In 1773, the Jesuit order was
even (temporarily) suppressed altogether by the Roman Catholic Church.
In 1724, meanwhile, a Qing emperor had condemned Christianity. The
unraveling of the once promising Jesuit mission to China is symptomatic
of an apparently widening gap in mutual appreciation between China and
Europe in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.
(HEA, 186)
After
the establishment of the Qing Dynasty in 1644, meanwhile, although a
scattering of embassies came to China from the Netherlands, Portugal,
Russia, and the Vatican ... there was little formal diplomatic contact
between China and the major western European countries. Substantial
private trade, however, began after the Manchus consolidated their
control and lifted previous bans on maritime trade in 1684. By this
time the leading European traders were now the British, who in 1664
imported a little over two pounds of a curious
Chinese leaf thought to have medicinal properties. In a local
southeastern dialect, this substance was called something that sounded
like “tea.” The British tea trade would soon grow to
enormous importance. By the early 1830s the British were annually
purchasing 30 million pounds of tea from China, taxes on which
“provided about one-tenth of the total revenue of England.” In the
meantime, however, a new restriction had been placed on European trade
with China. Beginning in 1757, the Qing Dynasty limited most Western
maritime trade to only one port: Guangzhou (Canton). (HEA, 186-9)
|