The senior seminar
serves as a capstone for the
General Education program at North Central and provides students with
the
opportunity to apply the skills they have developed through their
liberal arts
education in the context of an interdisciplinary theme or problem
chosen by the
instructor. In this section of the class, we will engage in a
role-playing game
in order to develop potential responses to the ongoing tensions between
the
People’s Republic of China (hereafter referred to as China) and the
Republic of
China (hereafter Taiwan), which many fear could produce the spark that
leads to
World War III.
Your
final grade will ultimately depend on my assessment of
your performance in each of the above areas, though the following
descriptions
should provide you with a rough idea of the defining characteristics of
students within particular grade ranges:
| A |
Consistently
demonstrates a deep understanding of the major concepts and themes of
the course, develops insights into their broader significance, and
maintains a high level of intellectual engagement in class discussions. |
| B |
Demonstrates a
serious commitment to the course
and a strong grasp of the major concepts and themes but with less depth
and/or
consistency than the “A” student. |
| C |
Demonstrates a basic grasp of the course material as well as a reasonable effort to
attend class
and participate in discussions. |
| D |
Demonstrates a minimal commitment to the
course
and a weak grasp of basic concepts and themes. |
| F |
Fails to demonstrate an acceptable
degree of
effort in the course through low attendance, inability to discuss basic
concepts and themes, missed assignments and/or plagiarized work. |
|
Please
note that using ChatGPT or a similar AI tool can be a helpful way to
generate
ideas, though their use may stifle the development of your own
independent
thinking and creativity. Moreover, presenting material that was
generated by
such tools as your own work (for example, cutting and pasting such
content
without citing the source) is PLAGIARISM. To avoid plagiarizing — and
the
consequences of violating the College’s academic dishonesty policy —
you should
(1) submit material that is in your voice and based on your
analysis
and understanding of the topic; and (2) cite all sources — including AI
software — when using content that you did not generate. Violations
will be dealt
with according to the college’s Academic
Integrity Policy.
Learning Outcomes
By
the end of the course, you should be able to:
1. communicate effectively using various
modes of expression
2. evaluate
information and approaches to complex problems
3. collaborate
effectively with others from diverse backgrounds
4. demonstrate
personal and social responsibility in various contexts |
Student
work for this course may be randomly selected for program assessment
with identifying information will be removed. Your grade for
this course will not be affected in any way, but if you do not want
your coursework
to be included in program assessment, please let me know.
Class Attendance & Participation
(25%)
The senior seminar is intended to help you
apply
the skills that you have developed through a liberal arts education by
engaging
in an interdisciplinary problem-solving exercise with your entire
class. Given
the collective nature of this work, your individual participation is
essential
for the success of our attempt to develop potential responses to the
China-Taiwan conflict. Toward this end, you will receive 10% for simply
coming
to class — though you will lose 2% for each unexcused absence over the
course of
the semester. You will also receive a 15% participation mark that will
reflect
your ability to demonstrate that you have made a sincere attempt to
read and
understand the assigned material, engage in class discussions, and
contribute
to the development of responses to the China-Taiwan conflict.
The Role-Playing Game
In
order to develop potential responses to the
China-Taiwan conflict, we will engage in a role-playing game in which
the
entire class will function as the “State Department
Advisory Committee on China-Taiwan Relations.” In the first half of the
course,
I (in my role as Committee Chair) will provide a general overview of
the
historical context that led to the conflict; in the second half of the
course,
you (as members of the advisory committee) will present “white papers”
(reports
that are intended to help readers understand an issue or solve a
problem) on
various aspects of the conflict. Toward the end, the committee will be
divided
into five groups, each of which will focus on one of the following
areas:
U.S.-China Relations, International Law, Negotiating a Settlement,
Geopolitical
Implications, and Military Preparations. Each group will develop a
presentation
to brief the rest of the committee on the particular issues associated
with
their area of specialization. After all groups have completed their
presentations, the committee will have a final session to draft an
Advisory
Report on the China Invasion Threat for the President of the
United States. The report should include concise statements summarizing
the
committee’s conclusions with regard to each of the five areas of focus
as well
as a final recommendation for the future direction of U.S. policy on
the
China-Taiwan conflict. In drafting this final section of the report,
the
committee should consider the following questions:
Should
we continue to support the status quo (i.e., leaving the status of
Taiwan unresolved, which has been the official U.S. position since the
Shanghai Communique of 1972)? Should we push for a negotiated
settlement in order to prevent a possible invasion (which could
potentially
lead to WWIII)? And in either case, how should we respond if the
Chinese do
initiate an attack on Taiwan? More specifically, if China attacks
Taiwan,
should the U.S.
(i) declare war on China
and immediately enter the
conflict,
(ii) support Taiwan’s efforts without formally entering the conflict
(as we
have done in the conflict between Russia and Ukraine), or
(iii) focus
on
diplomatic efforts to resolve the conflict without providing concrete
military
assistance to Taiwan (such as weapons, military intelligence, and
tactical support)?
|
Group Presentations (25%) &
White Papers (25%)
Although the first half of the course will
be
primarily dedicated to helping the class develop a general
understanding of the
historical context of the conflict, each class session will include
time for
groups to work on their presentation. As Committee Chair, I will spend
time advising
each group, but it is ultimately up to the group to decide how to
research
their topic, which “white papers” to write, who will write them, and
how they
will present their findings to the rest of the committee. Generally
speaking,
each student in the group is expected to give a presentation on the
white paper
that they wrote, though other approaches to the group presentation are
possible
with the permission of the Committee Chair (Professor Hoffert). To get
you
started, here are some initial questions to explore for each group:
|
Group 1: U.S.-China Relations
Is China a global
“superpower” — and if not, under what conditions would it become one?
How would
you characterize the current political and economic relationship
between the
U.S. and China? Should the U.S. work to preserve the status quo or if
changes
are desired, what are they and how should they be pursued?
Group
2: International Law
What is the current
legal status of Taiwan? Does China have a legitimate claim to Taiwan?
Does
Taiwan have a legitimate claim to independence?
Group
3: Negotiating a Settlement
What are the
potential options for a negotiated settlement? How would each option
affect
U.S. interests? Should we push for negotiations now in order to avoid
an
invasion in the future or maintain the status quo while using soft
power to
achieve our desired goals?
Group
4: Geopolitical Implications
How would China’s
annexation of Taiwan or the establishment of Taiwan’s independence
affect the
political and economic interests of China, Taiwan, and the United
States? How
would each outcome affect global politics and economics more generally?
Group
5: Military Preparations
Is China militarily
prepared to take Taiwan? Is Taiwan prepared to defend against a Chinese
invasion? How should the United States respond if Taiwan is invaded?
|
White papers should
be a minimum of 1000 words
and must include references to at least five “peer-reviewed”
sources, one of which must be The Boiling Moat (the required text
for this course); citations
may be in whatever style is typically used in your major. Please
note
that
using ChatGPT or similar AI tools will not be allowed in this course
since the writing assignments are meant to evaluate your ability to
comprehend the assigned readings and develop your own perspective on
the topic in question. Presenting AI-generated material as your own
work is PLAGIARISM and will be dealt with according to the college’s plagiarism
policy.
Students will receive
a unique grade for the white paper that they write, but the entire
group will
receive the same grade for the group presentation, so it will be
important for
you to work as a team and for each member to pull their own weight. And
remember, this is a cooperative effort, not a competition, so feel free
to work
with other groups. For more details, see the “Group Presentation” and “White Paper” rubrics below.
Winning the Game?
Since this is a team effort, there will
be no
individual winners; rather, “winning” will be defined in terms of the
overall
success of the committee’s efforts to produce high-quality
recommendations for
U.S. policy with regard to the China-Taiwan conflict. Accordingly, the
entire
committee will receive a “victory point” for each group that earns a
grade of
90% or higher on their presentation and the results of the game will be
characterized as follows:
• 0 Victory Points: The president was disappointed by the report
and
will look to other experts to determine the future direction of U.S.
policy on
the China-Taiwan conflict.
• 1 Victory Point: The president is impressed with parts of
the
report but will consider other perspectives before determining the
future direction
of U.S. policy on the China-Taiwan conflict.
• 2 Victory Points: The president is
impressed with
much of the report and will seriously consider its conclusions before
determining the future direction of U.S. policy on the China-Taiwan
conflict.
• 3 Victory Points: The president is quite
impressed
with the report and will use it as a framework for developing U.S.
policy on
the China-Taiwan conflict.
• 4 Victory Points: The president is
extremely
impressed with the report and will use it to redefine U.S. policy on
the
China-Taiwan conflict.
• 5 Victory Points: The president is deeply
impressed with the report and decides to adopt it as U.S. policy on the
China-Taiwan conflict.
|
In
addition to winning the president’s gratitude
and respect, all members of the committee will receive a 1% bonus for
each victory
point earned.
Personal Reflection on the Liberal
Arts (25%)
After finishing the role-playing game,
we will
turn our attention to the ultimate purpose of the course, which is to
help you
reflect on the value of the liberal arts education you received at
North
Central College. Your 1000-word paper should include responses to the
following
questions:
• What is a “liberal arts” education?
• Which specific aspects of the education
you
received at North Central embody the “liberal arts” principle?
• How did your liberal arts education help
you
develop potential responses to the China-Taiwan conflict?
• How do you anticipate using your liberal
arts
skills to achieve your post-graduation goals (personal and/or
professional)?
|
Your paper should provide references to
at least
three sources, which may be cited using the style that is typically
used in
your major. For more details, see the “Personal
Reflection on the Liberal Arts” rubric below.
• Pottinger, Matt (editor). The Boiling Moat:
Urgent Steps to Defend Taiwan.
Hoover Institution Press, 2024.
“White Paper” Rubric
|
|
Unsatisfactory
0 - .69
|
Good
.70-.79
|
Very Good
.80-.89
|
Exceptional
.90-1.0
|
MARK
|
|
LENGTH
|
<750
words |
750-1000
words
|
1000-1250
words |
>1250
words |
2.5%
|
|
STYLE
|
Ideas are poorly
expressed with substantial spelling and/or grammar issues
|
Ideas are adequately
expressed but there are many stylistic errors
|
Ideas are clearly
expressed with some stylistic errors
|
Ideas are eloquently
expressed with very few stylistic errors
|
2.5%
|
|
REFERENCES
|
There are no
references to relevant sources
|
There are references
to less than 5 credible sources that minimally support the paper’s
thesis
|
There are references
to at least 5 credible sources (including the course text) that
appropriately support the paper’s thesis
|
There are well-chosen
and skillfully used references to at least 6 credible sources
(including the course text)
|
5%
|
|
CONTENT
|
The paper shows little
understanding of the issues that are relevant to the China-Taiwan
conflict
|
The paper shows
minimal understanding of the issues that are relevant to the
China-Taiwan conflict
|
The paper
appropriately explores an issue that is relevant to the China-Taiwan
conflict
|
The paper develops an
insightful perspective on an issue that is relevant to the China-Taiwan
conflict
|
15% |
|
TOTAL
|
|
|
|
|
25%
|
|
“Group Presentation” Rubric
|
|
Unsatisfactory
0 - .69
|
Good
.70-.79
|
Very Good
.80-.89
|
Exceptional
.90-1.0
|
MARK
|
|
INDIVIDUAL LENGTH
|
<5
minutes |
5-6
minutes |
7-8
minutes |
9-10
minutes |
2.5% |
|
INDIVIDUAL DELIVERY
|
There was a
significant problem in the presentation
|
The content was simply
read and there was little eye contact and/or poor body language
|
The conmtent was
clearly presented with good eye contact, body language, etc.
|
Strong presentation
skills resulted in a high level of audience engagement
|
2.5%
|
INDIVIDUAL MEDIA
|
No audio-visual aids
were used to enhance the presentation
|
The content was
minimally enhanced by a PowerPoint (or similar) presentation
|
The content was
significantly enhanced by a
PowerPoint (or similar) presentation
|
The content was
greatly enhanced by a creative
PowerPoint (or similar) presentation
|
5% |
|
INDIVIDUAL CONTENT
|
The presentation does
not express a coherent perspective on the China-Taiwan conflict
|
The presentation
identifies a relevant issue and expresses a coherent position
|
The presentation
develops a thoughtful perspective on a relevant issue
|
The presentation
develops an insightful perspective on a significant issue
|
10%
|
|
OVERALL COHESION
|
There was no apparent
connection between the individual components of the presentation
|
There was some attempt
to connect the individual components of the presentation
|
There was a clear
connection between the individual components of the presentation
|
The group created a
highly cohesive presentation on their assigned topic
|
5%
|
|
TOTAL
|
Note:
marks for the first four categories will be an average of each member’s
individual score while the mark for “overal cohesion” will be based on
the group’s presentation as a whole.
|
25%
|
|
“Personal Reflection on the Liberal
Arts” Rubric
|
|
Unsatisfactory
0 - .69
|
Good
.70-.79
|
Very Good
.80-.89
|
Exceptional
.90-1.0
|
MARK
|
|
LENGTH
|
<750
words |
750-1000
words
|
1000-1250
words |
>1250
words |
2.5%
|
|
STYLE
|
Ideas are poorly
expressed with substantial spelling and/or grammar issues
|
Ideas are adequately
expressed but there are many stylistic errors
|
Ideas are clearly
expressed with some stylistic errors
|
Ideas are eloquently
expressed with very few stylistic errors
|
2.5%
|
|
REFERENCES
|
There are no
references to relevant sources
|
There are references
to less than 3 credible sources
|
There are references
to at least 3 credible sources that appropriately support the paper’s
thesis
|
There are well-chosen
and skillfully used references to at least 4 credible sources
|
5%
|
|
CONTENT
|
The paper shows little
understanding of the liberal arts and its relevance to education
|
There
is an attempt to define the liberal arts and reflect on its
significance to their education, the game, and their future goals
|
The
concept of a liberal arts education is clearly defined with thoughtful
reflections on their education, the game, and their future goals
|
There
is an insightful reflection on a liberal arts education and how it has
impacted their education, the game, and their future goals
|
15% |
|
TOTAL
|
|
|
|
|
25%
|
|

|